Do we have complete control over our health? This question has a variety of answers; and it can not be a simple yes or no. My opinion has two parts to it. I think that for the most part, we do have control over our basic health. We can control what goes into our bodies to monitor our weight. We can make sure we are dressed appropriately to walk out in cold weather to avoid catching a cold. Now, can we avoid getting sick in general? Probably not, but then we have to take care of our bodies with the correct treatments. On the other hand, cancer is not something we can particularly avoid. It can be cured, but we don't necessarily have control over it as human beings.
One of the arguments presented in class this week was the idea of "moral hazard." Moral hazard is basically saying that the second universal health care is applied that millions and millions of people that were previously uninsured would knock on the doctors office doors. Gladwell says this is simply not true. On page 60 in our universal health care book, he makes a very interesting point. Basically what he says is that just because we can go to the doctors office, doesn't mean we will. Would people really just wake up one day and feel like just going to the emergency room? Gladwell doesn't think so; and I am in agreement with his viewpoint.
Now, lets look at the opposition. Would there be more people going to the doctors in the first year or so of universal health care? Absolutely; BUT, can we be prepared for this? Most definitely. The United States is one of the most advanced countries in almost every sense of living except the health care system. We are behind Canada in all health statistics. Our infant mortality rate is extremely high compared to other countries. And on top of that, we even spend more of our GDP per year on our health care system. So do we want this same system? The time for the change is now.
I agree that there is no simple yes or no answer to controlling our health. I also agree that people wont be knocking down the doctors door. You also make a very valid point in your own opinion, and how what is one more tax on top of everything else that is being taken out.
ReplyDeleteI agree with the fact that control over our health seems to be in a grey area. Because we can control things like what we eat and if we exercise but we can't control cancer or anything like that. Good blog!
ReplyDeleteBrandon,
ReplyDeleteI agree with the majority of your blog! The last part about one more tax going unnoticed though concerns me. As of now, we, as teenagers, basically have no bills to pay but, one more tax cutting into a families paycheck can easily move them from the middle class line to below it. Our generation is making the decisions for what will come in the future and additional taxes could affect us negatively. Where will the line be drawn to keep adding "one more tax"?
Ciao Brandon,
ReplyDeleteGreat blog. Nice work responding to the topic and the readings.